1991 – Jack Wilhelm
1992 – Karoly Molnar
1993 – Doug Donaldson
1994 – Bob Lynch
1995 – Dr. Robert Stevenson
1996 – Edward H. Murphy
1997 – Jerry Rombach
1998 – Ernest A. Ensign
1999 – Walter Kaczay
2000 – Richard J. Elliott
2001 – None given
2002 – Gordy Cohagan
2003 – Friends & Families of East Elyria Little League
2004 – Roger Negin
2005 – Marcia Hersman
2006 – Hal Minnich
2007 – Connie Rusynyk
2008 – Doug Schmittgen
2009 – Ed Betzel
2010 – Jack Shumacher
2011 — Ron “Rick” Carr
2012 — Jim Mackert
2013 — Cooper “Coop” Hudnutt
2014 — Jim Tomsic

2015 — Ken Kaiser

2016 — Larry Dixon

2017 — Tim Gebhardt

2018 — Steve Kaminski

2019 — Jo Jo Guyeska

2022 — None given (Pandemic)

2021 — Steve Kirsh

2022 — Linda Schuster

2023 — Bill Troyer